Genres are for wimps. I mean this literally: it requires effort to overlook labels and understand that (nearly) all books, regardless of categorization, have value. That anyone possesses the innate ability to adore a romance as much as a thriller or classic. I tend to treat genres with the same suspicion as I do color theory or the Enneagram: who are you to tell me I can’t wear a cool red? Why shouldn’t my dream bedside stack include Patrick Radden Keefe and George Eliot and Beverly Jenkins?
My debut novel, A World Apart, rides under many banners. Sometimes I describe it as a “historical fantasy romance,” which is accurate yet unbearably wordy; other times I just say it’s Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, but with kissing. The process of writing it was an exercise in unlearning. As someone who studied and read primarily “literary” fiction, cut her teeth writing Buffy the Vampire Slayer fanfiction, and spent the last 10 years churning out personal essays, finding myself knee-deep in a novel about a queer magician in Victorian London and his 800+ year-old paramour was surprising, to say the least.
Genres often obscure more than they elucidate. Take two of our current most popular: weird girl fic and romantasy. Both genres are umbrella terms for “books for women,” both an attempt to capitalize on or commodify female purchasing power. Both genres are also, to my mind, less dissimilar than you might imagine. Here are five books that play merrily in the middle space.
Continue reading “5 Books on the Weird Girl Fic-to-Romantasy Pipeline, Recommended by Meghan Nesmith”